Everyone wants a distressed property because they are
thousands cheaper and are usually amazing “finds”. Right?
You already know the first thing I’m going to say so let’s get that part over with; it depends. There you didn’t want to
read that and I didn’t want to say that but it is how it is. Now, let’s hit a few points about that and see if we can’t stir up better reading.
Question for you, “What is “cheaper” and what is an “amazing find”?CHEAPER #1: Let’s agree that there are two kinds of “cheaper”. Right? Of course there is the initial price thing. Like, “I bought this house for $275,000 and
several similar sized houses just all SOLD for over $350,000 each.” That is cheaper initially. Usually that also means you just bought a fixer-upper and
you got into an area that may otherwise not have been possible. This is awesome when it happens when you also tell your broker one other thing. “I am ready, able and willing to fix this place up and take on the project mentally, physically and financially.” Nice buy in this case. Very cool. Even cooler, you
got one of those houses that need actually less repair and work than expected. This does happen and it is really REALLY cool.
CHEAPER #2: The other “cheaper” is a lot trickier. The other cheaper may look like one of the follow two scenarios:
Scenario #1:
“I bought a house already all fixed up because I got the remodeled house for a fraction of what it would have taken me to fix up the fixer.” Quite often, maybe more often, would you believe that the nicer house was actually the “NET CHEAPER” house because of the cash it may have taken to remodel the fixer? What do you think? Are you the “I can fix it all” person? or, are you the, “I’m not handy” or the” I can but I don’t want to” kind of buyer? Can you imagine these next two words showing up in your remodel; Scope Creep? If so, Scenario #1 is your cheaper. Buy the already done house and get the whole package cheaper than it would cost you to buy all the materials and labor. Not even counting the frustration and stress related to your time invested.
Scenario #2:
“I bought the fixer, had a great time remodeling it, and I ended up with sweat equity”. Is this you? These houses are out there and you have the skills to know the difference between a loser and a winner. If this is you, your broker pulls comps, and you use the wide expertise of your broker to discuss trends, pricing data and examples of remodeled homes nearby. You also may have carpentry and/or mechanical skills and know other tredespeople who do and who may assist you. Yes, Scenario #2 is your cheaper. You love it! It is plain fun!
Finally, what is an “amazing find”?
Isn’t it simply either one of the two scenarios above? Could the buyer who buys Scenario #1 be as able to brag about an “amazing find” as the buyer who bought Scenario #2? What would most skilled real estate brokers say? My experience is that they can definitely be equally great finds. Think about it this way. The net savings on either scenario could be equal even if one ended up with sweat equity and one did not. Why? The answer is because the “Sweat Equity” part is an additional benefit that the other buyer was never going to try for or realize. They won’t fix up a house themselves. So, each buyer saved money and ended up with their amazing find. I think “AMAZING” is truly in the eyes of the beholder who, THE WHO, buying the house.
So, bottom line:
A distressed property, like a Foreclosure or Short Sale is not always the best deal. It does depend on who is buying the property. Who are you? Find a great real estate broker who is willing to work with you whoever you are. Of course, I feel quite certain that you will find such a real estate broker at the Windermere Lloyd Tower Office. I am friends with brokers of other companies that impress me, but the Windermere Lloyd Tower Brokers impress me daily. I respect them and enjoy working with them every day. Check them out and see what you think.
several similar sized houses just all SOLD for over $350,000 each.” That is cheaper initially. Usually that also means you just bought a fixer-upper and
you got into an area that may otherwise not have been possible. This is awesome when it happens when you also tell your broker one other thing. “I am ready, able and willing to fix this place up and take on the project mentally, physically and financially.” Nice buy in this case. Very cool. Even cooler, you
got one of those houses that need actually less repair and work than expected. This does happen and it is really REALLY cool.


Using my broker’s iPad at Starbucks and just finished looking at houses….. This is a good way to look at it. Showed me this article to help me sort this out. Saw some scary bank for closures today and way better normal houses.
I bought a foreclosure recently. It was a strange process but my real estate agent kept me informed. I had a whole home inspection and he found that all the wires in the house had been stretched out for some reason. These was also missing drawers in the kitchen and a plumbing leak. My agent told me to try asking the bank for the repairs. They fixed the wires but not the kitchen. She seemed surprised that I got the repairs so I guess I did better than others have. There are a lot of little projects to do but so far so good. I think I fall somewhere in between your scenarios. I got a good deal and I am happy.
My husband and I have remodeled every home we’ve been in, then sold it when everything was done! We are at the stage that we don’t want any more major projects, so the best deal for us would be to buy something that was already done up. Maybe some smaller projects would be of interest to us. I do have a question though…
Do you think that short sale homes end up coming back on the market cheaper when they are bank owned??
I think you have it right! A good deal, but with need for major repairs that one cannot or will not do, is not always a “good deal” in the end. This is a good way to rethink one’s purchase.
From”Anonymous” private post:
Hi Ron,
I read your article on the blog post about foreclosed/short sale homes. I agree that not all such homes are a “good deal” in the end. It does depend on the buyer and condition of the home. Unfortunately, all such foreclosing/short sale homes drop the value of the other homes in the market. That’s the down side for people like me who might want to sell and buy elsewhere, but cannot because of the market.
Thank you for your insights,
Private Identity Local Portland Home Owner